7 Best Drugstore Eyebrow Pencil - Reviews And Buying Guides [2021] - Beauty mania

7 Best Drugstore Eyebrow Pencil – Reviews And Buying Guides [2021]

Best Drugstore Eyebrow Pencil

Defined and well-groomed eyebrows are essential for any makeup look. With a polished, appropriate eyebrow, your makeup will get a complete look.

No matter how much time you spend on your base and eye makeup, without properly defined eyebrows, you won’t look good.

In today’s makeup industry, you will get different brow products, like – brow pomade, brow gel, pencils, etc.

In this article, we will help you to choose the best drugstore eyebrow pencil.

In recent years, thick and defined brows have been on the trend. You can quickly achieve that using an eyebrow pencil.

The drugstore has a lot of eyebrow pencils to offer us at affordable prices. So you don’t need to spend a lot after a perfect eyebrow. 

To define your brows, you don’t have to get to a salon and spend hefty money. There are plenty of affordable options.

If you have very thin eyebrows, you can draw it with a pencil and later put on a clear gel that can make your brows look thick.

7 Best Drugstore Eyebrow Pencil Reviews [2021]

In the drugstore, you will find plenty of eyebrow pencils. Here are some of the popular pencils:

1. Revlon Colorstay Brow Pencil

This waterproof formula will stay up to 24-hours. This is one of the popular and best-selling eyebrow pencils from the drugstore.

The long-wearing formula will define your brows perfectly and give your makeup an amazing look.

It has an angled tip applicator that can be used for precise application. It provides a natural look to your brows.

This product is easy to use, and even beginners can easily achieve a defined, full brow.

This double-ended item has an eyebrow brush too. The brush softens the color and grooms the hair in place. Before using the pencil, brush-off your hair.


  • This is waterproof.
  • This eyebrow pencil is long-wearing.
  • This item is available in different colors.


  • Quantity is not enough.
  • It can be too thick.


This ultra-skinny brow pencil from NYX will work in both thick and thin eyebrows. The pencil is so precise that you will get a natural eyebrow. The extra thin tip can draw very thin brows that look more natural.

There is a built-in spoolie brush that you can use to brush and give an original shape to your eyebrows. Brushing your brows before using a pencil is very important.

You can get an idea of how you can draw the shape of your brows. It has a self-sharpening design, so the tip is always sharp. To create a full, natural brow, use small strokes with the pencil.

Overall, this definer pencil helps to get perfect brow shade with the natural appearing finish. Even to get extra fine-lines this product gives the crucial performance.


  • The ultra-fine tip makes this item special.
  • It gives a natural-looking thin eyebrow.
  • This pencil is available in different shades.
  • This is a cruelty-free product.


  • The pencil can be hard. It doesn’t easily glide on.
  • The tip is very small, not beginner-friendly.
  • The crayon is fragile.

3. L’Oreal Paris Makeup Brow Stylist Definer Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil

This eye definer pencil gives small and fine draws in the gaps of your eyebrows. The pencil is so thin that the hair will look natural. This is also waterproof and transfer-proof.

The brow definer can be used in sensitive eyes too. With this pencil, you can precisely define your eyebrows and give it a perfect shape. You will twist the pencil, and the product will come out.

So you don’t have to worry about sharpening the pencil. The other side of this pencil has an eyebrow brush. Which is soft and helps to brush your eyebrows. The formula is long-lasting and doesn’t smudge. 


  • This pencil is super pigmented.
  • Easy to use.
  • It has an ultra-fine tip.
  • This item is waterproof.
  • Available in different colors.


  • The quantity is not enough.
  • It easily breaks, so you will face difficulties to get the required shape while using it.

4. Maybelline New York Brow Ultra Slim Defining Eyebrow Makeup Mechanical Pencil

The Maybelline new your ultra-slim defining eyebrow pencil has a smooth glide formula and a built-in spoolie brush. With this pencil, it is very easy to have defined and precise brows.

The tip is very thin and has a fine texture that makes your brows look natural. It doesn’t give streaks. The ultra-slim tip is only half-millimeter that offers a hair-like natural stroke.

The formula glides on so smoothly and gives no breakage of the product.  It has six different shades. You can choose any color from blonde to dark according to your natural brow color.

Overall, to get the appealing polished look this brow pencil is quite dependable for its amazing performance.


  • The tip is ultra-fine and thin.
  • This product comes in six different shades.
  • It has a smooth, creamy texture.
  • It gives natural eyebrows.
  • Comes with a brush.


  • The tip doesn’t have any angle shape.
  • The brush quality is not good.
  • The product runs out fast.

6. e.l.f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil

This e.l.f instant lift brow pencil gives your eyebrows a life and provides the defined look. It is very easy to use, and for a quick brow day, this is perfect.

The dual-ended pencil has a brush on one side and a pencil on another side. The pencil has a creamy texture and glides on smoothly.

First, comb your hairs and then draw the eyebrows to get a flawless brow arch. The pencil side comes out with a twist opener, and you don’t need to sharpen the tip.

This super skinny-tip can easily reach on the sparse areas to get the complete coverage and even rub as well. Moreover, its soft bristles easily soaks excess grease from oily skin and gives the perfect finish.

E.l.f has a variety of shades in this line, so this has a color choice for every skin tone people. The pencil is also pigmented and stays for a long time.


  • This is a high-quality product at affordable prices.
  • This line has a variety of shades.
  • The pencil is very creamy and glides on smooth. 


  • The pencil runs out fast.
  • The product can easily break off. 

7. Milani Stay Put Brow Sculpting Mechanical Pencil

You can achieve a professional eyebrow look in no time with this Milani stay put brow pencil. This double-ended pencil grooms your brows and gives a sharp and defined look.

The micro angles tip glides on smoothly in your brow area and fills up the gaps, making your brows look bold and natural. It has five different shade from taupe to blond to dark brown.

You can get a versatile look using this product. With light strokes, you can get natural brows or can have defined and bold brows. It also has a brush side, that you can use to shape out the brows before drawing.


  • This line comes with six different shades.
  • Cruelty-free product.
  • The tip has an angled shape.
  • The tip gives fine and precise strokes.
  • An ideal sparse brows


  • For the amount of product, the price seems high.
  • The brush is not that much soft.

Why do we use an eyebrow pencil?

The eyebrow is an essential item in any makeup vanity. Correct and defined brow shape according to your face can really make a change.

If your eyebrows are properly shaped, it can lift your eyes and make your face look slim.

Well-groomed brows can make you look sharp, polished, and can make your eye look more beautiful, where a messy eyebrow can limit your makeup.

Eyebrow pencils are used to define the shape and fill in the eyebrows. They contain unique ingredients that can fill in the eyebrows and make them look thick. 

Why are eyebrows so important?

As I have mentioned before, the eyebrow can make you look polishes and give your face a definition.

A perfect shaped eyebrow can make your eye look bigger and brighter. It brings attention to your face.

Eyebrows also balance the shape and size of your nose. To use an eyebrow pencil, you need to choose a color that is close to the natural color of your brows.

Typically, taupe or dark brown goes with most of the people. Always make sure your pencil has a sharp tip so that you can draw your brow shape precisely.

Then start feeling the eyebrows with upward strokes. Use the pencil like a feather so that the brows look natural. Do not put pressure while filling up your brows.

My Thoughts

Among all these wonderful products, my favorite is the NYX Micro Brow Pencil. I love it for quite a few reasons.

I like the precise and beautiful brows. Not too thick, not too thin. It is very important to decide the density of your eyebrows, depending on your face shape.

This NYX micro brow pencil has a thin tip that helps me determine if I want a thick brow or medium dense brow.

The ultra-fine tip also provides natural strokes that look like real eyebrows. Also, I don’t have to worry about the sharpening as it twists up, and the product comes out.

The brush also has a good quality that helps to brush my brows before applying the product. This brow pencil is a good purchase in terms of the quality you get in this value.